SCORING
& HANDICAPPING PROCEDURE
This page describes how to score a sailboat racing event; it is arranged by time frame.
Notes:
- This procedure was first developed before the age of computerized
sailboat race scoring and has been gradually updated for the modern age. Forgive us if we still reference
using
pencil-and-paper.
- Scoring is not a private fiefdom. The scorer should never forget
that he or she is a member of the race committee, subject to direction
by the RC's head. Similarly, the PRO should keep the needs of the scorer
in mind form early event planning.
Obtain the handicaps.
The complete
Portsmouth Yardstick tables are available from US SAILING.
- Download Portsmouth handicaps, from
US SAILING or
SailWave.
- Get PHRF handicaps from SAIL PHRF Chair, Bob Malouff. For boats
without current PHRF certificates, the RC will assign the handicaps.
Decide to use wind-dependent handicaps for
Portsmouth.
They provide fairer results, than the DP-N numbers.
Reliable
wind instruments can be obtained for little money. If no wind measuring device is
available, the judgments of experienced sailors categorizing the conditions as Drifter,
Light, Moderate, or Heavy will produce more equitable results than
using non-wind-dependent handicaps.
In the Notice of Race &
Sailing Instructions:
Notice of Race:
Declare the scoring &
handicapping systems to be used. For a weekend or shorter event, the low
point system of Appendix A is most common. For a season-long series, a
high-point system could be better. Keelboats can use either PHRF or
Portsmouth; dinghies and multi-hulls use Portsmouth.
Sailing Instructions:
Invoke or describe the scoring system
and handicap system(s). If it's desired to give fewer points than entrants
plus 1 for those who don't start or don't finish a race, modify Appendix A,
paragraph 4.2.
If using PHRF, decide between time-on-distance (TOD)
or time-on-time (TOT) and declare that RC-assigned handicaps
are not subject to redress, appeal or protest, except by SAIL PHRF members.
Invoke or describe the throw-out scheme, and possibly the use of throw-outs in the tie-breaking
scheme. Unmodified, Appendix A declares 1 throw-out regardless of number of races completed
(even if only one)
and does not use throw-outs in tie-breakers at all.
Be sure you're ready
Computerized scoring
"Set up" files for the event. Practice, get the current tables & formulas, test-score with dummy results.
If using paper & pencil, Make enough copies of the scoring &
handicapping forms to handle all expected races & fleets. Making two copies of each,
using good, old-fashioned carbon paper is a very good idea. Include a space on the
registration form for the full boat class with variations and the skippers initials
agreeing to that classification.
- Or, check out & practice with your computer scoring program -- on the same equipment
you'll be using to score the races.
Verify handicaps
In consultation with its skipper, determine the
appropriate handicaps for each boat at registration. Many classes have variations
that are handicapped differently. Write the complete description of the boat, as printed
in the handicap chart or certificate, on the registration form and have the skipper sign it.
Assigning handicaps should be done with the involvement & blessing of the PRO. It is
not solely the arena of the scorer.
After registration & before
competitors meeting:
Confirm handicaps with PRO
The principal race officer is responsible for the
regatta's racing. The scorer is a member of his/her race committee.
Group boats into fleets
using their
handicaps and their weights. A handicap fleet should not have more boats than a
one-design fleet. The closer the handicaps, the better the racing. In fluky air (e.g.,
Colorado) lighter boats generally outperform heavier boats on handicap.
Set the starting order
according to the handicaps
of the fleet. Dont relegate the handicap folks to the last start and require the
faster handicap boats to sail through slower fleets started earlier.
On the water:
- Use courses that include beats, runs, and reaches about equally
and try to achieve elapsed times on the order of 1 hour.
- Courses with reaching legs have fallen out of favor for most boats at
most events. Windward/leeward courses are now considered more tactical
and strategic.
- Courses much shorter or much longer than an hour distort the
racing to favor either higher or lower handicaps.
Record initial race data
Sail numbers of competitors at
check-in, starting times,
periodic wind speeds (See the Beaufort Scale.) and
courses on the RC Sheet .
Record finish times
On the RC Sheet. Use clock
times (time-of-day). Use a water-proof writing device (soft pencil) if youre in an
open boat. The recorder should sign the RC Sheet.
- When recording sail numbers & finish times, write them as the boats finish.
Do NOT write them in any order other than as the boats finish.
Do NOT -- at this stage -- try to organize into fleets. Use the format below. (See here for a downloadable example.)
| Sail # | Time | Class |
Comment |
| 5372 | 1342:46 | U-20 | |
| 68 | --43:05 | U-20 | Protest flag |
Getting "fancy" with the recording is certain to introduce errors.
Very often, boats are finishing more frequently than can be recorded.
When pushed, record only sail number & time; leave other info for slack
periods.
- If you have any handicap fleets, you should record sail numbers &
times for all boats. It is too difficult to use different procedures for different fleets.
If you have only one-design fleets, record the finish time for the first
boat in each fleet.
- Sail numbers & times go together. Record them together.
When convenient, the recorder should copy the class, sail number, starting time, and
finish time onto the Handicapping Sheet, separating racing groups. The scorer can then
compute elapsed times, corrected ties and finish positions. These are simple calculations
and can be accomplished with a hand calculator in about 30 seconds per boat. Both the
recorder and the scorer should sign the Handicapping Sheet.
Computer scoring:
Enter the sail numbers & times directly
from the finish sheet into your scoring program. This avoids the use of intermediate forms,
which can introduce errors.
After each days racing
Complete the scoring
Complete the RC sheets as soon as possible
after each race (and, if paper-and-pencil scoring, Handicap Sheets and the current
Cumulative Score sheets).
Unlike fleet racers,
handicap racers may not know who won individual races until they see the numbers. Quick
posting also enables the correction of inadvertent errors before they become Requests for Redress.
- The clock doesn't start running on such a request for redress until the scores are
posted. It's embarrassing to hand out trophies, then ask for them back.
At the end of the event
Send results to SAIL.
E-mail
the results files, .blw or HTML. If scoring on paper mail copies of RC, Handicap & Scoring Sheets.) We need these to publish results in the newsletter, to score tour
points, and to submit to US SAILING for inclusion in handicapping statistics. More often
than not, someone from SAIL will be at your event and would be happy to hand-carry the
copies.
Keep a file
Do not destroy the records or computer files until the season is over. They may be needed in a
protest, request for redress or appeal.
Corrected Time (CT) and Elapsed Time (ET) are in decimal minutes and Distance (D)
is in statute miles
| Formulas |
|
Portsmouth Yardstick: |
Corrected Time = Elapsed Time x 100 / ( D-PN or Hcn ) |
| PHRF Time on Distance (TOD): |
Corrected Time = Elapsed Time - (Distance x PHRF / 60 ) |
| PHRF Time on Time (TOT): |
Corrected Time = Elapsed Time x TCF |
| SAIL PHRF Time Correction Factor: |
TCF = 715 / ( 515 + PHRF )
In SailWave, "715" is the A factor & "515" is the B factor. |
|
Hours-Minutes-Seconds to Decimal Minutes:
|
Decimal Minutes = ( Hours x 60 ) + Minutes + ( Seconds / 60 )
|
As altitude increases and air thins out, the force exerted by wind
diminishes with respect to its velocity. At the altitudes encountered within the SAIL
region, it is probably more equitable to judge wind conditions from their effect on the
water according to the following table than to measure velocity with an instrument.
The Race Committee should observe sea conditions at the start, during, and at the
finish of the race and determine the average Beaufort Number for that race. Take care to
observe that the wind strength you observe is the same as that of the race course. Click
here for the Beaufort Scale.